Skip to content

Budget dinners.
Real families fed.

Pizza & Flatbreads

The Perfect Pizza Topping Formula

One sauce, one main cheese, one protein, one or two vegetables and a finishing flavor. Plus five pizza nights that do not feel the same.

4 min read

A cook adding toppings to a pizza from bowls of cheese, sauce and vegetables
Photo: Or Hakim on Unsplash

Overloaded pizzas are the most common reason homemade pizza comes out soggy. This formula keeps each pizza balanced and gives you a way to invent your own.

The formula for one 12-inch pizza

LayerHow muchExamples
SauceAbout 1/2 cupTomato, pesto, garlic ricotta, barbecue
Main cheese5 to 6 ouncesMozzarella, provolone, fontina
Protein3 to 4 ounces, cookedPepperoni, sausage, chicken, bacon
VegetablesAbout 1 cup totalPeppers, onion, mushrooms, olives
FinisherAfter bakingBasil, arugula, hot honey, Parmesan

Rules that save a pizza

  • Cook raw meat first. Sausage, bacon and chicken should be fully cooked before they go on.
  • Pre-cook watery vegetables. Sauté mushrooms, spinach and peppers for a few minutes.
  • Slice thinly. Thin onion and pepper slices cook through in 10 minutes; chunks do not.
  • Add delicate toppings after baking. Fresh herbs, arugula and prosciutto wilt or burn in a very hot oven.

Five pizza nights that don't feel the same

NightSauceCheeseToppingFinisher
Classic MargheritaTomatoFresh mozzarella—Basil, olive oil
Pepperoni Hot HoneyTomatoMozzarella, ParmesanPepperoniHot honey
White Garlic ChickenGarlic ricottaMozzarellaChicken, spinachLemon zest
Pesto FlatbreadPestoFresh mozzarellaCherry tomatoesBalsamic glaze
BBQ ChickenBarbecueMozzarella, smoked goudaChicken, red onionCilantro

Start with our homemade pizza dough and no-cook pizza sauce.

Keep cooking
All pizza & flatbreads
The Weekly Table letter

Pull up a chair.

New recipes, dinner plans and kitchen tips, straight to your inbox. No spam, and you can unsubscribe any time.

We use analytics cookies to understand how visitors use our site. Functional cookies (session and page variant) are always set. See our Privacy Policy.